The FPA Friday Digest
27 February 2026
FPA rallies against 'structural discrimination'
Regular readers of the FPA Friday Digest will be aware that over recent weeks we have been conducting research around pEPR participation levels – and I hope you will forgive us if this week's Digest focuses on this and on the actions we have taken to date to escalate the issues it has uncovered.
We shared our findings yesterday in a series of open letters to Defra, PackUK and the relevant regulators because it is the role of a trade body to speak clearly and firmly on behalf of its members.
Let me be equally clear: our members support environmental responsibility. They accept their legal obligations and are complying with them. What they cannot accept is a system that appears to concentrate costs on those who report correctly, while others who should be contributing may sit outside effective enforcement.
When that happens, compliant businesses are effectively discriminated against.
Regulation must be applied evenly. If it is not, the result is an uneven playing field and a competitive disadvantage for those who follow the rules. Contracts are lost. Margins are eroded. Jobs are put at risk. That is not conjecture, it is what members are reporting.
There is also a growing perception within the sector that the scheme is becoming primarily a revenue-raising mechanism, rather than a framework designed to ensure fairness, transparency and environmental effectiveness. Whether that perception is justified or not, it is damaging, and it must be addressed.
The cost of EPR must be spread across all companies that are liable, not disproportionately borne by those who are visible, compliant and reporting correctly.
Our research has been deliberately conservative. We have taken the lower bound of what can be evidenced and excluded borderline cases. If anything, our findings represent a minimum estimate. We have chosen to understate rather than overstate.
The findings sit alongside the anecdotal evidence we have been collecting recently. Thank you to all those who have so far contacted us with details of businesses they believe are potentially liable under EPR rules, but are somehow slipping under the radar. Please keep them coming.
We are prepared to share the intelligence we have received with the authorities in strict confidence, but only subject to written assurance that information provided in good faith will be properly assessed and followed up. Past experience has left members questioning whether intelligence submitted results in visible enforcement action. Confidence cannot be restored if concerns are simply absorbed without consequence.
Naturally, we will continue to urge members to remain compliant. However, frustration is growing. Some businesses are seeking independent legal advice, others are openly questioning whether sustained participation is commercially viable if enforcement gaps persist. That should concern policymakers.
EPR can work. But only if it is complete, proportionate and consistently enforced. Fairness is not optional in a regulatory system, it is fundamental.
Rest assured, the FPA will continue to press for transparency, proper policing and an even application of the rules.
Mike Revell, FPA executive chair
Coverage in The Grocer
Also yesterday The Grocer reported on our analysis of incorporation patterns within packaging-relevant sectors and their interaction with the pEPR framework.
While the article predominantly focuses on packaging-adjacent company formations, it is important to highlight a wider and equally significant finding.
The association’s research identified not only an acceleration in packaging-adjacent incorporations, but also a substantial increase in new company formations across broader manufacturer, wholesaler and distributor categories. The annualised run rate in the most recent cohort is significantly higher than baseline periods.
This broader surge provides important structural context.
'Packaging-adjacent' companies represent only those identifiable through relevant SIC codes and keyword analysis. It remains possible that packaging supply activity may also sit within wider manufacturer or wholesale classifications not captured within the narrower packaging-adjacent filter.
Taken together, these trends demonstrate that the FPA’s findings are conservative and represent a lower-bound assessment of potential scope exposure. The research does not assume that all newly incorporated entities are obligated under pEPR, nor does it assert non-compliance by individual businesses. Rather, it identifies divergence between incorporation growth in packaging-relevant sectors and visible producer registration participation.
The recent confirmation that government will close the Year 1 funding shortfall provides welcome short-term certainty for compliant producers. However, long-term revenue resilience depends on participation completeness and confidence that modelling assumptions reflect evolving market realities.
The FPA supports the environmental objectives of EPR. Our focus remains on structural integrity to ensure that environmental ambition is matched by fair cost distribution, modelling transparency and enforcement visibility.
Our open letters invite constructive engagement on these matters and the association will continue to work collaboratively to help ensure the playing field is level and compliant businesses do not become victims of unintentional structural discrimination.
The recent confirmation that government will close the Year 1 funding shortfall provides welcome short-term certainty for compliant producers. However, long-term revenue resilience depends on participation completeness and confidence that modelling assumptions reflect evolving market realities.
The FPA supports the environmental objectives of EPR. Our focus remains on structural integrity to ensure that environmental ambition is matched by fair cost distribution, modelling transparency and enforcement visibility.
Our open letters invite constructive engagement on these matters and the association will continue to work collaboratively to help ensure the playing field is level and compliant businesses do not become victims of unintentional structural discrimination.
Our public statement
he Foodservice Packaging Association (FPA) has written formally to Defra, PackUK and the Environment Agency to raise structural questions relating to participation completeness, revenue resilience and enforcement visibility within the Packaging Extended Producer Responsibility (pEPR) framework. We have also brought the matter to the attention of Chris Bloore MP, chair of the APPG Group for the Packaging Manufacturing Industry.
This follows confirmation from PackUK that a funding shortfall was identified in Year 1 following revised tonnage submissions. Government has agreed to close this gap on a one-off basis, and disposal fees will remain as set out in producers’ Notices of Liability.
While this provides short-term stability, the FPA believes the episode underscores the importance of ensuring that the full obligated producer population is consistently captured within the scheme.
The association’s position is grounded in an analysis of Companies House incorporation data aligned with producer registration trends. Its findings are based on conservative inclusion criteria and focus on system-level design considerations rather than individual company compliance.
The FPA remains committed to constructive engagement with policymakers and regulators to ensure that environmental ambition is matched by fairness, transparency and financial robustness. In particular, we believe the system must avoid outcomes that inadvertently disadvantage compliant businesses through uneven application of obligations.
The association is also committed to ensuring pEPR operates fairly and effectively. If you are aware of information that may be relevant to participation completeness within the scheme, you may contact us in confidence by emailing compliance@foodservicepackaging.org.uk
Any information shared will be treated responsibly.
FPA members can access the full text of the letters and other related content within the EPR section of the FPA Member Hub.
Non-members can access the full public explainer document, a message from Mike Revell the FPA's executive chair, some FAQs and a public explainer which outlines why we have taken this action via the button below.
In brief: our requests to Defra
Following confirmation this week that government will close the Year 1 funding shortfall on a one-off basis, the FPA has written to PackUK to seek greater clarity around modelling assumptions and participation capture.
We have asked PackUK to:
- Publish the assumptions underpinning obligated population modelling.
- Provide greater transparency on how participation completeness is assessed.
- Clarify how revised tonnage submissions affected fee calculations.
- Explain how revenue resilience will be strengthened in future years without reliance on further intervention.
- Outline steps being taken to reduce late-stage data adjustments.
Our objective is to ensure that disposal costs are distributed across the full obligated population and that modelling reflects current market dynamics.
FPA members can access the full text of this letter within the FPA Member Hub.
In brief: our requests to PackUK
Following confirmation this week that government will close the Year 1 funding shortfall on a one-off basis, the FPA has written to PackUK to seek greater clarity around modelling assumptions and participation capture.
We have asked PackUK to:
- Publish the assumptions underpinning obligated population modelling.
- Provide greater transparency on how participation completeness is assessed.
- Clarify how revised tonnage submissions affected fee calculations.
- Explain how revenue resilience will be strengthened in future years without reliance on further intervention.
- Outline steps being taken to reduce late-stage data adjustments.
Our objective is to ensure that disposal costs are distributed across the full obligated population and that modelling reflects current market dynamics.
FPA members can access the full text of this letter within the FPA Member Hub.
In brief: our requests to the Environment Agency
We address enforcement visibility within high-churn market segments in our letter to the Environment Agency.
Our requests include:
- Clarification on how below-threshold and newly incorporated entities are monitored for potential future obligation.
- Confirmation of the Agency’s approach to detecting potential under-registration within packaging-relevant sectors.
- Information on how enforcement resources are aligned with emerging incorporation trends.
- Assurance that any intelligence shared in confidence will be formally logged, assessed and followed up appropriately.
We recognise the challenges of regulating dynamic markets. Our aim is to strengthen participation integrity and enforcement confidence within the scheme.
FPA members can access the full text of this letter within the FPA Member Hub.
In brief: our requests of the APPG for the Packaging Manufacturing Industry
In this correspondence we hav asked the chair of the All-Party Parliamentary Group (APPG) for the Packaging Manufacturing Industry to help ensure parliamentary awareness of emerging structural trends.
We have asked the APPG to:
- Consider the wider economic implications of participation divergence.
- Examine the potential impact on compliant SMEs and mid-sized packaging manufacturers.
- Explore the implications for employment and regional economic resilience.
- Support transparency around modelling assumptions and scope calibration.
- Facilitate constructive dialogue between industry, policymakers and regulators.
We believe that parliamentary oversight is essential to ensuring that environmental policy objectives are achieved without unintended structural discrimination against compliant businesses.
FPA members can access the full text of this letter within the FPA Member Hub.
EXTERNAL EVENTS
Stakeholder Engagement Forums – February to July dates
Dates and links to the next tranche of Circular Economy Stakeholder Forum meetings. No registration is required, the Microsoft Teams link accompanying each forum will provide direct access to that meeting.
Defra recommends individuals wishing to attend save each link to their calendars. No reminders will be sent.
March Forum – Tuesday 3 March: 14:30 to 16:00 Link to access forum
April Forum – Tuesday 7 April: 14:30 to 16:00 Link to access forum
May Forum – Tuesday 5 May 14:30 to 16:00 Link to access forum
June Forum – Tuesday 2 June: 14:30 to 16:00 Link to access forum
July Forum – Tuesday 7 July: 14:30 to 16:00 Link to access forum
FPA NEWS
FPA 2026 Awards: spotlight on the 'Unsung Hero' finalists
With less than a week to go until the FPA 2026 Annual Awards, the excitement levels among the FPA team are rising faster than the decibel level at the pre-dinner cocktail bar!
We’ll be circulating the official guest list this afternoon, so keep an eye on your inbox. It’s your chance to see who’s joining you for what promises to be a brilliant evening of celebration, recognition and the occasional questionable dance move.
If you’ve secured your place (if you haven’t have a quiet word with Lisa as she may have one or two up her sleeve), now is the time to:
- Retrieve your dinner suit or posh frock from the wardrobe and evict the moths.
- Check your bow tie is still fit for purpose.
- Practice your gracious winner’s smile (and your even more gracious "we’ll get them next year” version).
- Dust off your dancing shoes, because history tells us they will be required.
- And perhaps rehearse your best poker face because …
... yes, the casino tables will be open once again, but before anyone alerts the compliance team, it's strictly tokens only.
This is our industry’s night to shine – to celebrate innovation, resilience and the people who keep foodservice packaging moving across the UK and beyond.
We're looking forward to welcoming you!
FPA in the news
Essential reading
The Grocer: EPR tax to get government bailout amid fury over funding black hole. Read more here
PackUK: Year 1 Extended Producer Responsibility for packaging fees update. Read more here
Defra: Councils urged to crush more fly-tippers' vehicles. Read more here
BBC: One in four councils to miss food waste collection deadline. Read more here
letsrecycle.com: PRNs back online after digital service delays. Read more here
Sky: Two people arrested in pEPR fraud and money laundering probe. Read more here
Food Manufacture: UK's DRS management organisation appoints senior leaders. Read more here
Packaging Journal: Researchers develop compostable food packaging made from wood with a coating of mycelium, the root-like network of fungi. Read more here
Circular: Exchange for Change publishes mandatory DRS logo requirements ahead of 2027 launch. Read more here
Guardian: Fly-tipping across England reaches record high as fines decrease and only 0.2% of incidents result in court action. Read more here
Quote of the week and post of the week
Given not everyone has access to The Grocer, we couldn't resist including a few of the quotes from our executive chair Mike Revell used in yesterday's article:
"If you design a system with thresholds, the market will organise itself around those threshods and that is what our investigation is showing".
"Companies that follow the rules should not be financially disadvantaged for doing so".
"The EPR system should reward compliance – not penalise it".
"This is like a time bomb ready to go off and when we have serious job losses right across the packaging industry it is too late, the damage will have already been done".
Join the FPA
The Foodservice Packaging Association represents the interests of its members at all levels and works hard to ensure its members are better represented, better informed and better connected.
FPA members receive early sight of this Digest at 6:15 a.m. each Friday morning.
Interested in joining the FPA?